Tuesday, January 21, 2014

Is there anything better than a 5-star review? Oh yeah!

I’m really proud when I get a great review.  I know it’s delightful for any author and so it should be. But when it happens on one of my books, then of course for me it’s personal. Let’s face it, 5 stars are the best you can get. And when your readers let you know you’ve given them a great read, well then the confirmation that you’ve done your job makes a lot of the drudgery of creating a good story worthwhile.

And no matter what anyone tells you, that prominent rating is important. Let’s face it, not everyone will be passing out 5-star reviews and it’s understandable and acceptable. Not everyone who chooses your book likes the same thing.

It could be the characters they dislike, the genre or maybe they just aren’t partial to say… too many cuss words. I’ve actually had reviewers tell me they were keen on the plot and even the romance but they didn’t like the sex.

Fair enough.

In some extremes, people can be so fickle that if they dislike a heroine's name it can sway their overall enjoyment to where the story is good but there’s just something about it that isn’t quite right…..humm!

Heck, I know for a fact that in one of my earlier books I had a hero who smoked, and that totally turned off a fan. Since the tale took place in the 60’s I was trying to be realistic to the times. Didn’t matter! For her and maybe others, it was a no-no.

Another time, while discussing reviews with a book group, I was told that quite a few of the ladies didn’t like men with hairy chests. That it could certainly influence their liking for one of the main characters if continued references were made to that fact. Would it lessen the enjoyment for them? Possibly. Could it change a 5 to a 4? Good grief, I hope not. 
I must say everyone who gives me a sweet review is adored and revered but there’s just something about getting that highest accreditation from a reviewer whose job is reading a whole lot of books and passing out judgements. When that happens, then I’m over-the-moon ecstatic.
My 5-star validation from Goodread’s “To Be Read” reviewer: Shyla Colt

I bet you figured this was leading up to this moment – right?? Just have to share…

So? Is there anything better than a 5-star review?

Sure there is.

Thirty-Two 5-star reviews.


Next blog – the difference in the actual message readers share in their reviews!




  1. Congratulations, Mimi. You earned bragging rights. *g*

  2. Thanks so much, Joan. It's fun to be able to brag once in a while :-) I promise not to get too carried away with this type of behavior. LOL

  3. Congrats Mimi... I look forward to reading the series. Together Again is on my Amazon Wish List. I didn't want to read too much of the review... sometimes that is harder for me to not go in with preconceived notions and expectations. I try to be good about doing reviews when I'm done reading but I do know I'm still behind on a few from last year. :(

  4. Hi Lynn, welcome to Believe. I'd love to have you as guest on the blog any time you'd like to visit.:-)